.svg)
Hiring remotely gives you access to top talent. But it can also make it harder to spot warning signs. Without in-person interviews or team dynamics, those red flags can slip through the cracks fast. That’s why having a keen eye early in the process is your best defence.
Already lining up interviews? It’s worth checking out our guide to screening and interviewing for remote marketing roles. A solid process helps prevent red flags from ever making it to the shortlist.
Common red flags in remote marketing candidates
- Vague or overly flexible work habits
- Poor written communication
- No clear results in past roles
- Defensive when faced with feedback
- Disorganised applications or work history
1. Misalignment with remote work culture
Red flag signs:
- They talk about remote work as just “working from home,” rather than flexibility, self-discipline or delivering results.
- Cannot describe how they structure their day or stay motivated when working independently.
- Have no examples of working autonomously and may rely heavily on being managed.
Try asking:
“How do you typically structure your workday when no one else is setting deadlines for you?”
You’ll quickly see if they’ve thought about rhythm, priority setting and ownership.
2. Poor communication habits
Watch for:
- Applications that are unclear, too brief or sloppy.
- Inability to customise tone based on context, such as chat versus email versus documentation.
- Missed cues in async messaging, including slow replies or confusion on simple details that should be clear.
Try a task:
Ask them to summarise a complex campaign or project they’ve worked on in a short written paragraph, as if explaining it to a colleague asynchronously.
You’ll see how clearly and concisely they can communicate in writing.
Clear communication is key, not just during hiring, but especially if they will lead and manage remote marketers.
3. No clarity or results in past work
Warning signs:
- A resume full of buzzwords like “ninja” or “guru,” with little explanation of what they actually did.
- Inflated role titles that don’t match the scope.
- Difficulty explaining the “why” or real outcome behind their campaigns.
Try asking:
“Can you tell me about a campaign you worked on — what the goal was, what you actually did, and how it performed?”
This question cuts through fluff and gets to real contribution and results.
Need more ideas? Try our 25 interview questions for remote marketing roles.
4. Reluctance around collaboration or feedback
Red flags may include:
- Talking only in terms of individual wins, with no mention of teamwork.
- Becoming defensive or vague when asked about constructive feedback or failure.
- Avoiding phrases like “we” or “we learned that” and only focusing on “I did this” instead.
Try asking:
“Tell me about a time you received feedback you didn’t agree with. How did you handle it?”
Watch for how they talk about the other person. Defensiveness often shows up here.
5. Inconsistent or disorganised
Indicators:
- Sloppy details in their application, like the wrong company name, poor formatting or typos.
- A career path with lots of gaps or job-hopping, without a clear narrative.
- Interview setup issues, such as being late, missing links or not following instructions.
Try a light test:
Send an interview confirmation with clear instructions and a prep link. Do they follow them without issue?
Sometimes the simplest task surfaces the clearest signals.
Final tip: Patterns matter more than perfection
One tiny red flag doesn’t mean they’re a no-go. Everyone has off days. But if the warning signs stack up across multiple touchpoints, it’s worth digging deeper.
Use follow-up questions or small tasks to clarify. If it still feels off, trust your gut. And when in doubt, your hiring process matters. The insights, tools and links in our Employer’s Guide to Hiring for Remote Marketing Jobs can help you avoid these issues entirely.
Want to skip to profiles of candidates already pre-vetted for clarity, communication and culture fit? Post your role on Howard →
Read next: Avoiding red flags is just the start. A strong onboarding plan helps your new hire stay aligned, engaged and motivated. Here’s how to build one that actually works.
